Why is there a fresh row on Mullaperiyar?
The Story So Far
- Meeting Cancellation: The Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF) canceled its May 28 meeting, which was set to consider Kerala’s request for a new Terms of Reference (ToR) for conducting an Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) for a new dam at Mullaperiyar in Idukki district.
- Purpose of the Meeting: The meeting was called to assess the potential environmental impacts of constructing a new dam, as Kerala sought to acquire a new ToR for this purpose.
Why the Meeting Was Called
- Dispute Between States: Any developments related to the masonry gravity dam at Mullaperiyar, which is owned and operated by Tamil Nadu, are fiercely contested by both States at various legal and governmental levels.
- Kerala’s Request: Kerala’s latest request for a new ToR to facilitate the EIA for a new dam sparked a strong response from Tamil Nadu.
What is Tamil Nadu’s Objection?
- Dependency on Dam Water: Tamil Nadu’s primary objection stems from the fact that it relies on the water released from the Mullaperiyar dam to irrigate its arid Theni, Madurai, Sivaganga, and Ramanathapuram districts.
- Violation of Supreme Court Order: Tamil Nadu argued that considering Kerala’s proposal for a new Terms of Reference (ToR) for the EIA would violate an earlier Supreme Court order from 2018, which specified that any such studies required the Court’s permission.
Why Does Kerala Want New Terms of Reference?
- Detailed Project Report (DPR): Kerala requires extensive data to prepare a Detailed Project Report (DPR) for constructing a new dam and to engage Tamil Nadu in discussions regarding the new dam.
- Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA): An EIA is required because the proposed dam site is located in the Periyar Tiger Reserve, a designated Protected Area that mandates environmental clearances.
- Clearance from National Board for Wildlife (NBWL): Since the Periyar Tiger Reserve is both a tiger and elephant reserve, clearance from the NBWL is necessary.
- Forest Land Permission: Given that the proposed dam construction involves non-forestry activities and tree felling, permission from the Union Ministry and the Supreme Court is required.
Is There a Scope for Consensus?
- Long-standing Legal Battle: Kerala and Tamil Nadu have been engaged in a long-standing legal battle since 1996.
- First Phase: The initial phase of the legal contentions between the two States focused on the safety concerns of the existing Mullaperiyar dam.
- Second Phase: The subsequent phase in 1998 saw both States filing several Public Interest Litigations and writ petitions, challenging various actions taken by each other’s governments.
- Potential for Future Legal Battles: Given the recent actions of the Kerala government, further legal disputes could emerge before the Supreme Court.
The message from the Andhra Pradesh bifurcation
Scant Nostalgia – Telangana
- Disappearing Vitriol: The intense political discourse regarding the bifurcation of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana has largely faded.
- Hyderabad in Focus: For the people in the shrinking Andhra Pradesh region, only Hyderabad remains in their memory of the new Telangana state.
- Historical Unity: The two regions were unified under one political authority for about 150 years until the division in 1956.
- Separate Journeys: Despite years of shared political rule, the formation of distinct states did not foster enough unity to prevent their separate paths.
Where States Stand
- Impact of Bifurcation: The division of Andhra Pradesh provides insight into how reconfiguring state boundaries can affect political influence.
- Shift in Political Order: Andhra Pradesh’s representation in the Lok Sabha has decreased from 42 seats to 25, making it smaller than both Tamil Nadu and Karnataka in terms of parliamentary seats.
- New Political Rankings: Telangana, with 17 Lok Sabha seats, is now smaller than Kerala, making it fifth in the political order among southern states.
- Unequal Political Equations: When smaller states exist alongside larger ones, the political landscape can become imbalanced, possibly causing strain on the federal system.
The Cracks Will Surface
- Political Delays: Grievances on both sides of the division may take time to surface, but they are bound to manifest eventually.
- Andhra Pradesh’s Capital Attempt: Andhra Pradesh’s bid to build a world-class capital was hindered by an emphasis on direct benefit transfer (DBT) welfare programs, which consumed a significant amount of time.
- Unfulfilled Promises: Issues such as unmet commitments on special category status and financial aid for capital city construction, alongside improper asset division, will not remain overlooked by political leaders.
- Historical Reorganization Insight: The linguistic reorganization of India required careful thought and extensive debate before being implemented, underscoring the need for a thoughtful examination of the Andhra Pradesh bifurcation and its aftermath.
- Mature Examination Needed: A deeper, more thoughtful analysis is essential to establish a stable foundation for the nation’s Republic in light of the ongoing issues.
Nipped in the bud
Criminal Activity – Baby Smuggling
- Socio-Economic Factors: Criminal activities like baby smuggling often arise from a mix of socio-economic elements, such as poverty and wealth, alongside unmet needs or desires.
- Recent Racketeering Incident: The recent baby smuggling racket in Telangana, involving 11 arrests, is a case in point.
- Inter-State Gang: The gang was involved in smuggling children from Delhi and Pune, selling them to prospective parents in Telangana and Andhra Pradesh.
- Financial Gain: The cost for a baby ranged from ₹1.80 lakh to ₹5.50 lakh, with brokers earning between ₹50,000 and ₹1 lakh in commission.
Insight into the Case
- Poverty of Biological Parents: Some cases involve impoverished biological parents selling their newborns.
- Smuggling from Government Hospitals: Another factor is smuggling from government hospitals where security is weak.
- Eager Couples: On the flip side, there are couples eager to have children who are frustrated by the lengthy legal adoption process, which can take two to four years.
- Government Action Required: The government should implement effective poverty alleviation schemes, raise awareness about adoption options, create youth employment opportunities, eliminate unnecessary bureaucratic hurdles in adoption, and strengthen policing to curb such activities.
Fewer women are being hired for leadership positions
News Context
- Representation in Workforce: While there has been an increase in women’s representation in the workforce over the years, LinkedIn’s Economic Graph data indicates a stagnation since 2022, and a decline in 2024.
- Senior and Leadership Roles: Progress in promoting women to senior and leadership positions has slowed in recent years.
- Industries with Low Representation: Women hold fewer positions in manufacturing, construction, and oil and gas industries.
Women in Workforce
- Workforce Participation: The representation of women in the overall workforce grew from 23.9% in 2016 to 27.3% in 2022, and then decreased slightly to 26.8% in 2024.
- Senior Leadership Positions: The highest percentage of women in senior leadership roles was in the education sector (30%). However, this representation in other sectors remains limited.
- Compliance Issues: Reports suggest that the Companies Act, 2013, which requires women directors on company boards, is not being strictly enforced.
Does inequality lead to growth?
News Context
- Statements and Rebuttals: Rahul Gandhi’s focus on issues of redistribution and Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s polarized response have brought discussions on inequality to the forefront.
- Inequality Findings: Researchers from the Paris School of Economics have determined that inequality in modern India surpasses that during the colonial era.
- Positive Aspects of Inequality: Some level of inequality can be beneficial as it motivates entrepreneurs to start businesses, thereby creating jobs and improving the welfare of others.
Monopoly Power and Consumption
- Billionaires and Market Dominance: Business groups led by billionaires often have significant monopoly power in their respective markets, allowing them to set prices rather than letting market forces determine them.
- Markup and Monopoly Effects: These businesses can charge higher mark-ups above production costs due to their monopoly power, leading to lower real wages in terms of purchasing power.
- Impact of Monopolies: This monopoly influence can result in lower real wages, as well as decreased levels of output and investment, contributing to the current cost-of-living crises experienced in developed economies.
Inequality and Growth
- Investment and Wages: Before creating new capital stock, wages are paid to workers who contribute to building it. These wages then flow into the economy, stimulating the income of goods-sellers and triggering a wider cycle of economic activity.
- Multiplier Effect: The increased income from workers and goods-sellers leads to a greater overall income than the initial investment. This is known as the ‘multiplier effect,’ where investment raises incomes by a greater proportion than the original investment.
- Consumption Proportion: The multiplier effect depends on the proportion of consumption from incomes, which ensures sustained economic activity.
Redistribution and Growth
- Taxation and Investment: According to Michal Kalecki, taxing wealth does not necessarily deter investment. As long as businesses have high expectations of future profits, they will continue to invest despite taxes on wealth.
- Impact on Investment: While some business owners may hesitate due to potential wealth conversion challenges, a healthy economy can continue to encourage investment.
- Benefits of Redistribution: Redistribution can strengthen the multiplier process, promoting growth even if some billionaires limit their investments. It’s not a universal solution, but when used alongside other policy measures, curbing inequality can contribute to a more robust and healthier economy.
Can domestic MFs invest in their overseas counterparts?
News Context
- SEBI Proposal: The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has released a consultation paper suggesting a framework that would allow domestic Mutual Funds (MFs) to invest in their overseas counterparts, or Unit Trusts (UTs) that invest a portion of their assets in Indian securities.
Framework’s Purpose
- Indian Securities Attraction: SEBI’s proposal acknowledges India’s robust economic growth and the appeal of Indian securities for foreign investors. This has led various international entities, including indices like MSCI Emerging Markets Index, ETFs, MFs, and UTs, to allocate assets toward Indian securities.
- Investment Ambiguity: There’s a lack of clarity regarding investments that have exposure to Indian securities, creating uncertainty and discouraging domestic MFs from participating in such instruments.
- Potential Investment Allowance: SEBI’s review suggests that permitting investments with limited exposure to Indian securities could benefit domestic MFs, facilitating a broader range of investment opportunities.
What Proposals Has SEBI Tabled?
- Investment Cap: SEBI proposes a cap of 20% on investments made by overseas instruments (in India), ensuring a balanced approach to facilitating investments while avoiding excessive exposure.
- Manager Autonomy: SEBI emphasizes that investments should be made autonomously by the manager, without influence from investors or undisclosed parties.
- Transparency in Disclosures: Public disclosure of the portfolios of overseas Mutual Funds (MFs) and Unit Trusts (UTs) is sought to maintain transparency.
- Conflict of Interest Prevention: SEBI advises against any advisory agreement between Indian mutual funds and overseas MFs/UTs to prevent potential conflicts of interest.
In fight against Nipah, scientists find new way to generate virus-like particles in lab
News Context
- Scientific Breakthrough: Researchers at the Institute of Advanced Virology (IAV) have pioneered a new method to produce non-infectious Nipah virus-like particles (VLPs) in laboratory settings.
- Enhanced Safety: This innovative approach provides a safe and effective platform within a biosafety level-2 (BSL-2) laboratory environment for developing neutralising antibodies against the NiV.
- IAV’s Mission: The achievement brings the IAV closer to its goal of developing monoclonal antibodies and antivirals against Nipah virus and similar pathogens.
Nipah Virus
- Highly Pathogenic Virus: Nipah virus is a zoonotic paramyxovirus known for its high pathogenicity, causing fatalities in up to 80% of human cases.
- Research Challenges: Previous studies on Nipah virus have been constrained due to the stringent biosafety measures required for handling this BSL-4 pathogen.
- Importance of Neutralisation Assays: Virus neutralisation assays are crucial for developing and evaluating vaccines, immunotherapies, and conducting fundamental research on the virus.
- Shift to BSL-2 Labs: Traditionally conducted in high-security laboratories due to the infectious nature of the virus, these assays can now be safely performed in BSL-2 laboratories across the country.
More Sophisticated
- Non-Infectious VLPs: Virus-like particles (VLPs) resemble viruses in structure but are non-infectious. They serve as valuable tools for analyzing viral binding and entry kinetics.
- Advanced Technologies: The introduction of NanoBiT technology and “HiBiT-tagged” VLPs (featuring a highly sensitive 11-amino acid peptide) enhances the sophistication of these platforms.
- Accelerated Potential: The inclusion of the HiBiT tag accelerates their role in antiviral drug screening and vaccine development.
- Need for Further Studies: Comprehensive research using various neutralising antibodies and antivirals to determine their effectiveness in blocking the virus entry is essential.
Tonga volcano could cause unusual weather for rest of decade: study
Tonga Volcano
- January 15, 2022 Eruption: The Hunga Tonga-Hunga Ha’apai (Hunga Tonga) eruption in the Pacific Kingdom of Tonga created a tsunami and sent sound waves around the globe.
- Climate Impacts: A new study investigates the eruption’s effects on winter weather, suggesting potential long-term impacts on our climate.
A Cooling Smoke Cloud
- Sulphur Dioxide and Aerosols: Typically, volcanic smoke and sulphur dioxide lead to a temporary cooling effect on the Earth’s surface. Sulphate aerosols create a shading effect until they settle out or are washed out.
- Water Vapour Instead of Smoke: In the case of Hunga Tonga, the underwater eruption produced minimal smoke and a large amount of water vapour. The intense heat from the eruption turned a significant amount of seawater into steam, sending it into the stratosphere.
- Stratospheric Water Vapour: The water vapour, not clouds or rain, ended up in the stratosphere, causing unusual conditions and potentially influencing weather patterns.
Research Findings
- Ozone Hole: The large ozone hole observed from August to December 2023 was partially influenced by the Hunga Tonga eruption. Simulations had anticipated this effect nearly two years in advance.
- Water Vapour’s Role: The water vapour generated by the eruption had just enough time to reach the polar stratosphere over Antarctica, leading to the enlargement of the ozone hole. Once the water vapour dissipated, the ozone hole began to close.
- Southern Annular Mode: The positive phase of the Southern Annular Mode during the summer of 2024 was associated with the extended presence of the ozone hole.
- Impact on Global Temperatures: Despite the ozone hole’s extended presence, the overall impact of Hunga Tonga on global temperatures, as a measure of climate change, remains minimal.
- Misattributing Temperature Trends: The extremely high temperatures observed in recent times cannot be attributed to the Hunga Tonga eruption.